≡ Menu

Court Finds Personal Jurisdiction Over Corporation’s Officers and Directors Living Out-of-State

In a case heard before the U.S. District Court of Nevada in the last year, the question of whether a state had personal jurisdiction over the corporation’s directors and officers was addressed. In January of 2017, the Court found that the exercise of jurisdiction by the State of Nevada over the directors and officers named in a derivative did not offend traditional notions of fair place and substantial justice.

In Sonoro Invest, S.A. v. Miller, 2017 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 9657, 2:15-cv-02286-JAD-CWH( D. Nev. Jan. 24, 2017), a shareholder of a Nevada corporation filed a derivative suit against four of the corporation’s directors and officers. Arguing that they did not live in Nevada and that their contacts with Nevada were not so continuous and systematic that they are “essentially at home” in Nevada, three of the defendants filed motions to dismiss the action for lack of personal jurisdiction. They further argued that the court lacked specific jurisdiction over them because their actions as officers and directors were not directed at or felt in Nevada, where their entity is incorporated but conducts no business operations. The defendants also moved to transfer venue to Ohio where “nearly all aspects of the litigation have substantial contacts.”

Citing the Nevada Supreme Court’s holding in Consipio Holdings, BV v. Carlberg,282 P.3d 751 (2012), the District Court of Nevada dismissed the defendants’ motions to dismiss. As stated by Judge Dorsey:

“I find that defendants’ purposeful acts designed to harm Abakan, a Nevada corporation, for their own personal benefit, combined with the notice that NRS § 78.135(1) provides and Nevada’s director-consent statute, are sufficient to confer personal jurisdiction over defendants for Sonoro’s derivative claims here. I also find that consideration of these reasonableness factors demonstrates that requiring Goss, Takkas, and Miller to defend Abakan’s derivative claims in this jurisdiction “does not offend traditional notions of fair place and substantial justice.” Nevada has an interest in adjudicating the derivative claims of a Nevada corporation to which Nevada law applies, and Sonoro plainly has an interest in obtaining convenient and effective relief and has selected this forum.”

The Court reasoned that while an individual’s position as a Nevada corporation’s director does not automatically subject that individual to jurisdiction in Nevada, the defendants’ purposeful actions in harming a Nevada corporation established contacts with Nevada and affirmatively directed conduct toward Nevada. Based on these purposeful actions coupled with the interest of both the plaintiffs and the State of Nevada in utilizing Nevada as a forum to adjudicate claims related to a Nevada corporation, it is not unreasonable that the officers and directors defend the lawsuit in Nevada. Under the circumstances, the defendants may have reasonably anticipated being hauled into court in Nevada.

The attorneys at Glass & Goldberg in California provide high quality, cost-effective legal services, and advice for clients in all aspects of commercial compliance, business litigation, and transactional law. Call us at (818) 888-2220, send an email inquiry to info@glassgoldberg.com or visit us online at glassgoldberg.com to learn more about the firm and to sign up for future newsletters.