A recent case heard in the Northern District of California resolved a priority issue between a secured lender and judgment creditor pursuant to the take-free rule of Article 9. The case involved a debtor who granted a consensual security interest in a deposit account to a secured lender and a judgment creditor who levied the same deposit account.
In Stierwalt v. Associated Third Party Administrators, 2016 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 68744, 89 UCC Rep. 2d 921 (N.D. Calif. 2016), the defendant, Associated Third Party Administrators (ATPA), received a $12 million loan from CAM, which retained a blanket security interest in all of ATPA’s assets, including “deposit accounts.” The promissory notes held by CAM were designated as “senior in right of payment” as to “all other indebtedness of the company.”
Later, the plaintiff, Stierwalt, obtained a judgment against ATPA and filed a writ of execution that garnished ATPA’s deposit accounts in one particular bank. Before the bank, U.S. Bank released any funds to Stierwalt, CAM filed a statement which claimed a perfected security interest in the deposit account funds.
Stierwalt did not dispute that CAM’s security interest in the funds in the deposit account had attached. However, the court concluded that CAM had not perfected its security interest in the debtor’s accounts as original collateral because it had no “control” over the account under UCC §9-104. There was no such control by CAM because: (1) CAM was not the debtor’s depository bank, (2) there was no third-party control agreement, and (3) the deposit accounts were not put and listed in CAM’s name as “customer.”
CAM also made the argument that it had a security interest in all the debtor’s receivables, collected and deposited into the debtor’s bank account as “derivative proceeds.” The California court concluded that, based on contract documentation, ATPA had “contract rights” in payments from its clients that were proceeds deposited into the U.S. Bank account.
Stierwalt argued that because the service contract proceeds were commingled with other company funds in the deposit accounts, CAM’s security interest was lost because the proceeds were no longer “identifiable.” The court disagreed and found that CAM’s security interest was properly perfected.
While it could be said that both sides made convincing arguments in support of their respective positions, based on a detailed analysis of UCC § 9-332(b), the court gave priority to the judgment creditor. The California court concluded that the take-free rule contained in Article 9 gives transferees from a debtor’s deposit account priority over third parties.
UCC §9-332(b) provides:
A transferee of funds from a deposit account takes the funds free of a security interest in the deposit account unless the transferee acts in collusion with the debtor in violating the rights of the secured party.
The court mentioned the Official Comment 2 to §9-332 and the broad protection it provides to transferees who take funds from a deposit account. The court pointed to this protection for transferees as ensuring that security interests in deposit accounts do not restrict the free flow of funds. Such protection also reduces the risk that a secured party will make a claim to any property the transferee purchases with the funds. Also, concerning recovery of payments, Article 9 has traditionally highly valued the finality of transactions. Any opportunity to overturn or suspend a completed transaction should be severely limited under Article 9.
The attorneys at Glass & Goldberg in California provide high quality, cost-effective legal services, and advice for clients in all aspects of commercial compliance, business litigation, and transactional law. Call us at (818) 888-2220, send an email inquiry to info@glassgoldberg.com or visit us online at glassgoldberg.com to learn more about the firm and to sign up for future newsletters.
