≡ Menu

Lessons From In re Sunnyslope Housing Ltd. Partnership

In First S. Nat’l Bank v. Sunnyslope Hous. Ltd. P’ship (In re Sunnyslope Hous. Ltd. P’ship), 2017 U.S. App. LEXIS 9198 (9th Cir., 5/27/2017), the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals permitted a bankruptcy debtor to cram down a first-position deed of trust because of restrictive covenants in junior position deeds of trust. The lender, in this case, First Southern National Bank (“First Southern”) argued that the court’s ruling would discourage future lending in similar circumstances.

The Ninth Circuit disagreed that future lending would be discouraged for like projects, noting “… in this case, First Southern bought the Sunnyslope loan at a substantial discount, knowing of the risk that the property would remain subject to the low‑income housing requirements. Valuing First Southern’s collateral with those restrictions in mind subjects the lender to no more risk that it consciously undertook.”

First Southern Bank, which was not the original lender, had knowledge of the restrictive covenants in the junior position deeds of trust when it purchased the loan based on the fact that the Loan Sale Agreement indicated that the property was subject to “other covenants, conditions, and restrictions.”

But the lesson from all of this is that secured lenders must be proactive and propose their own Chapter 11 plans. Simply objecting to plan confirmation as a method of protecting their interests is not always the best strategy. First Southern Bank could have better protected its interests and proposed a plan of reorganization which effectively:

  • eliminated all of the low-income housing provisions in the junior position deeds of trust, and then distributed a portion of this added value to the case’s other creditors and junior lienholders;
  • allowed it to foreclose on the property and then shared a portion of the profits with junior position creditors;
  • voided the junior position deeds of trust entirely. This is effectively what the debtor did as it actually extinguished the deeds of trust at the end of a 40 year period. It is likely creditors would have favored such a plan over the Debtor’s plan.

The attorneys at Glass & Goldberg in California provide high quality, cost-effective legal services, and advice for clients in all aspects of commercial compliance, business litigation, and transactional law. Call us at (818) 888-2220, send an email inquiry to info@glassgoldberg.com or visit us online at glassgoldberg.com to learn more about the firm and to sign up for future newsletters.