≡ Menu

Ascentium Sued For Suspicious Finance Lease Transactions

Recently in the early spring of 2016, Ascentium Capital was the named defendant in two Texas District Court lawsuits connected to a business arrangement whereby doctors would sell home health care, administered by nurse practitioners hired by the vendor. Ascentium financed $45,000,000 of these deals involving a small number of iPads and a license to use a home health care product! The Plaintiffs are seeking damages as well as certification of a class action.

The vendor, MHT sold these licenses for $300,000 to doctors and allegedly promised the doctors a low-risk opportunity including:

  • A line of credit in the amount $75,000 provided by Ascentium to subsidize start-up costs;
  • No fees or interest associated with the license;
  • No requirement to make payment on the lines of credit;
  • The option to return the license at any time by “novation” whereby the license is resold to another physician;
  • Proprietary software for CMS requirements (Medicare and Medicaid).

The “equipment,” related to this business arrangement consisted of a license, three iPads, and off the shelf software for billing, all for the “low” cost of $300,000. Most of the deals are alleged to have never progressed beyond the initial details leaving many physicians with substantial obligations based on personal guaranties to Ascentium.

The agreements between the parties to these transactions also contained standard “hell or high water” clauses, contractual provisions whereby a lessee agrees to make payment of its obligation to the lessor no matter what the circumstance, come hell or high water.

The complaint alleges that Cliff McKenzie, CFLP, a senior officer of Ascentium, had knowledge of the fraudulent practices and was receiving kickbacks of approximately $20,000 monthly from MHT. If true, this may arguably make MHT the agent of Ascentium, which could defeat the hell or high clause.

Ascentium has moved to dismiss the lawsuit arguing that the doctors are attempting to avoid their financial obligations because of their choice to do business with an unrelated enterprise, MHT. However, Ascentium does not deny that McKenzie had an “under the table” deal with MHT.

Of course, financing worthless collateral may not be a good business practice, as evidenced by the $300,000 price tag for a few iPads and some software. As Ascentium is owed $45,000,000 in lease payments on this program, it remains to be seen to what negative extent the company will be affected if these obligations are disallowed.

While hell and high water clauses may protect the lessor of equipment in most scenarios, past cases involving NorVergence and Royal Links indicate they may not in circumstances presented by the Ascentium case.

The attorneys at Glass & Goldberg in California provide high quality, cost-effective legal services, and advice for clients in all aspects of commercial compliance, business litigation, and transactional law. Call us at (818) 888-2220, send an email inquiry to info@glassgoldberg.com or visit us online at glassgoldberg.com to learn more about the firm and to sign up for future newsletters.