≡ Menu

An Analysis of California Senate Bill 297 As Amended

SB 297 was introduced in the California Senate in 2016 to expand the licensure and regulation of finance lenders and brokers by including finders, i.e., individuals that facilitate loans between borrowers and lenders. The latest version of SB 297, amended on April 17, 2017, now refers to “finders” as lead generators. Reaction to the amended version finds attorneys, scholars, and observers alike questioning various aspects of the bill.

The bill amends the California Finance Lenders Law by increasing licensing and registration requirements while expanding oversight of lead generators. Some believe it’s unclear under SB 297 whether a licensed broker or lender also needs to obtain a separate license to be a lead originator. This would probably necessitate some exemption by amendment or regulation.

While the bill claims to seek to distinguish the acts of lead generators from the acts of brokers, it does little to allow companies to make the distinction between a finance broker and a lead generator. Many believe that these terms seem to overlap and are often indistinguishable regardless of any statutory distinction. Lead generation is defined broadly under the bill so that it could apply to all kinds of regular syndication or referral type activities.

The bill seems to do little to expand or clarify the definition of finance broker to include the activities performed by lead generators. Based on the definition of lead generator in § 22010.5 as any person who, for compensation or an expectation of compensation, helps facilitate a loan based on activities that constitute lead generation as designated by the statute. If no deal is ever finalized, the lead generator must still comply with California law.

When a lead generator generates the lead but the lender does not make the loan, the lead generator is acting with an expectation of compensation. Therefore, under SB 297, the lead generator must have a license and comply with other statutory requirements despite the fact that the transaction may never be consummated.

It’s also been stated by some critics that SB 297 is redundant of existing regulation of broker and lender. The bill also seems to increase administrative duplication by forcing licensed or exempt lenders to oversee and police finders especially if the finder has its own license. The bill is also duplicative as it establishes additional annual reporting requirements although lead generated transactions already appear in the annual reports of brokers and lenders.

The bill further exposes lenders to liability simply for compensating a lead generator who has made a materially false or misleading statement to the borrower or engaged in a deceptive, misleading or unfair act or purpose. The bill requires lenders to implement policies and procedures to oversee the business practices of a lead generator. These policies and procedures include monitoring whether the lead generator maintains compliance with state and federal law. It seems harsh to make a business subject to discipline for any misrepresentation or deceptive act or practice of a lead generator when the lender does not have true, direct control over the lead generator.

Many California lenders believe that the CFLL’s current rules regarding loan finders are vague and unclear, thus resulting in uncertainty as to what lead generation activities may lawfully be performed. SB 297 seems to fail in providing any lack of clarity while exposing companies to liability for the actions of lead generators. Some believe that the bill also unnecessarily increases oversight and reporting requirements.

The attorneys at Glass & Goldberg in California provide high quality, cost-effective legal services, and advice for clients in all aspects of commercial compliance, business litigation, and transactional law. Call us at (818) 888-2220, send an email inquiry to info@glassgoldberg.com or visit us online at glassgoldberg.com to learn more about the firm and to sign up for future newsletters.