≡ Menu

Court Rules That Predispute Contractual Jury Trial Waivers Are Unenforceable In California Notwithstanding Choice of Law Clauses.

In a decision regarding enforcement of predispute contractual waivers of jury trial, the California Court of Appeal found that even when the contract contains an otherwise valid choice-of-law clause in which the parties have agreed to be governed by the laws of a state that enforces such waivers, California fundamental public policy precludes enforcement of such predispute contractual waivers of jury trial.

In Rincon EV Realty LLC v. CP III Rincon Towers, Inc., 2017 S.O.S. 501, (First District, Div. Four) (1/31/17), the California Court of Appeal decided a case in which the borrower of funds for a San Francisco construction project contractually agreed with its lender to have the law of New York govern their transaction. Further, the borrower waived the right to jury trial to resolve any issues between the parties.

At the trial level, the plaintiff-borrower requested a jury trial on claims of fraud, breach of contract, and other violations of the agreement. The court decided that the choice-of-law clause and waiver were enforceable and granted the defendants’ motion to strike the jury demand. The trial court relied on Nedlloyd Lines B.V. v. Superior Court (1992) 3 Cal.4th 459 in making its decision.

At the trial level, the plaintiff-borrower requested a jury trial on claims of fraud, breach of contract, and other violations of the agreement. The court decided that the choice-of-law clause and waiver were enforceable and granted the defendants’ motion to strike the jury demand. The trial court relied on Nedlloyd Lines B.V. v. Superior Court (1992) 3 Cal.4th 459 in making its decision.

In reviewing the lower court’s decision, the Court of Appeal utilized principles set forth in § 187 of the Restatement Second of Conflict of Laws. Under the Restatement approach, a court must first determine (1) whether the chosen state has a substantial relationship to the parties or their transaction, or (2) whether there is any other reasonable basis for the parties’ choice of law. If neither of these tests is met, the court is not required to enforce the parties’ choice of law.

But the analysis does not end here if either of the foregoing tests is met. At this point, the court must determine whether the applicable state’s law, in this case, New York state law, is contrary to a fundamental policy of California. A court will then enforce the parties’ choice of law if there is no conflict between law and policy. However, should a fundamental conflict exist with California law, the court must then determine whether California has a ‘materially greater interest than the chosen state in the determination of the particular issue . . . .’ (Rest., § 187, subd. (2).)

Despite the court’s finding that there was a substantial relationship between the State of New York as the parties had conducted the entire loan transaction in New York, the Court of Appeal held that under Nedloyd, the choice of law was unenforceable and the validity of the jury waivers was governed by California law.

Section 631 of the California Rules of Civil Procedure state that the right to jury trial is “inviolate” and may only be waived in six different scenarios, which all apply only after a lawsuit is filed. Therefore, any predispute agreement specifying that any lawsuit between the contracting parties will be adjudicated in a court trial, rather than a jury trial, is unenforceable.

The attorneys at Glass & Goldberg in California provide high quality, cost-effective legal services, and advice for clients in all aspects of commercial compliance, business litigation, and transactional law. Call us at (818) 888-2220, send an email inquiry to info@glassgoldberg.com or visit us online at glassgoldberg.com to learn more about the firm and to sign up for future newsletters.