≡ Menu

California Federal Court Rules Defendant in TCPA Case Can’t Compel Arbitration Based on Notice in Website Terms of Use

California Federal Court Rules Defendant in TCPA Case Can’t Compel Arbitration Based on Notice in Website Terms of UseThe U.S. District Court for the Central District of California has ruled that a defendant in a TCPA case cannot compel arbitration of a proposed consumer class action suit because the consumer was unaware of the arbitration provision in the Terms of Use page on the defendant’s website.

The case — Nghiem v. Dick’s Sporting Goods — was brought by plaintiff Phillip Nghiem against Dick’s Sporting Goods (DSG) and Zeta Interactive Corp. (Zeta) for alleged violations of the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA).  Nghiem had opted into DSG’s mobile alerts text messaging subscription service and six months later, opted out of the service by texting the word “stop” to the program’s number.  Nghiem received a reply text message stating that he had unsubscribed and would not receive any more mobile alerts.

Nghiem alleged that over the next six months, he continued to receive mobile alerts from DSG in violation of the TCPA and filed a proposed class action.  DSG and Zeta moved to compel arbitration, stating that the plaintiff was bound by the Terms of Use on DSG’s website to arbitrate his claims.  Nghiem argued that he was unaware of the arbitration provision and that even if he had agreed to it, the agreement does not cover TCPA claims nor can it be enforced by Zeta, a third party.

In denying DSG and Zeta’s motion to compel arbitration, the Court deferred to the Ninth Circuit’s reasoning in regard to browsewrap agreements which “purport to bind users simply by their existence, no matter whether the user has actually viewed them. Because of this lack of assent on the part of consumers, courts enforce browsewrap agreements with reluctance, and will generally only do so when a consumer has ‘actual or constructive knowledge of a website’s terms and conditions.’”

The Court found that the facts in the case were insufficient for it to determine if the plaintiff had actual knowledge of the Terms of Use on DSG’s website, stating that actual knowledge is not something to be “safely assumed” and defendants had not provided any evidence that the plaintiff had actual knowledge of the arbitration agreement.

The attorneys at Glass & Goldberg in California provide high quality, cost-effective legal services and advice for clients in all aspects of commercial compliance, business litigation and transactional law. Call us at (818) 888-2220, send an email inquiry to info@glassgoldberg.com or visit us online at glassgoldberg.com to learn more about the firm and to sign up for future newsletters.